If We Are Witnessing the Death Spiral of the Cult of Attacking Play, Let’s Appreciate Its Impact.
The Evolution of a Movement can be characterized by clear stages.
1. The Grand Vision
An inspiring figure or coaches introduce a revolutionary approach offering a panacea for alienated and vulnerable people.
And so it goes. They’re getting ready to storm the compound in Australia. The gunships are circling. Smoke is rising from the sidelines. One individual, vulnerable, anxious, the words HIGH RELEASE POINT displayed prominently as a statement, has come staggering through the lines and is removed with discretion to a different team elsewhere.
Do you recall the beginning, when optimism reigned? The era of early Bazball, of Bazball without brains.
2. Love-Bombing
Cult leaders guarantee a reboot, optimism ahead, camaraderie, salvation together who all believe in the big idea.
What was this thing at first? Just men on a balcony enjoying success. Body art. Forearms. Focus. Confident masculinity. Admittedly, The squad often say they don’t use the label, ironically since it’s not recognized, what did we see?
Yet it’s clear what it is. It’s the player playing a shot so unconventional it defies description. It’s the adrenaline of Ben Stokes at his peak, a demeanor suggesting: thoughtful warrior, beard made of wood, untamed style, so authentically Modern Savage you almost imagine to look down and see him playing on the ground bare-chested and cradling a wild salmon.
It’s Ben Duckett often seen speaking publicly, resembling a cheerful animal in a waistcoat, uttering phrases such as we’re breaking down traditions. Certainly, the energy, for quite a long time, was entirely positive.
3. The Growth Phase
Development stage. Togetherness strengthened via memorization of key phrases. These beliefs are often illogical as a test of “true belief”.
Am I alone? The criticism, the anger, the feeling of letdown following the initial loss feels overblown, too much. England batted badly on the field, as history shows. They were torn apart defensively during a brief period when tactics failed, outplayed by the batsman batting like England but better, adaptive to conditions, an athlete shining with aura.
And now we have this the attacks, the rage, the perception of the team as a failure. The feeling seems to be that losing isn’t enough, they must be humbled, to be cleansed, obliterated, defeated through sheer skill of the bowler’s action, the low-fi orthodoxies of Scott Boland, out there celebrating achievements with a bashful smile as if receiving a pleasant gift. How will they respond?
4. Hate Bonding
Challenges surface because of mistakes. But the cult cannot admit errors. It starts to feed on hostility externally.
The fact remains, half a week out from the second Test, we are at an intriguing moment in the story of this approach. England could quite easily win in the next Test through aggressive play. Alternatively, failure may follow. And if they do lose it appears we really might be entering the death cult phase.
Prior to that, a couple of points to note about this. In the past, during the initial excitement, of passion and hope, a column appeared calling it a phenomenon. There was outrage, which proved the point because everyone knows how to confirm something definitely isn’t a cult is should followers react defensively denying scrutiny of the philosophy.
The developments recently is just as interesting. Criticism of the approach has turned into a movement. Social media is furious, disappointed commentators, shots of angry middle-aged followers overseas cheated out of three days of cricket, reminiscent of people wanting fairness.
Meanwhile, there is the broader context of the opponent’s mixed more culturally hard-wired exasperation with the aggressive tourists, claiming, your cherished traditions and have honed as part of your identity from others, it’s just a joke ultimately.
And this is the real point. It’s all cults. Bazball was a cult because cricket is a cult. In fact, English cricket has always been a cult, a clique, a private event, a closed world with two hundred years of tradition and mystery defining it. It has long been where entry is limited. It’s the imperial sport of the nation, the pioneering brand. And guess what, the country is a phenomenon, a system of unknown levels, a place that literally still has a king.
The team have been sealed up in this environment for years. Attempting to break free, to build a better atmosphere, they are just repeating their own experience, building another enclosure, a limited community, however with 15 cool guys and a leader encouraging individuality provided you conform.
Focus on the moment. Confront risks. But no matter how fast and far you run, you’re always basically in the same place.
Considering this, now is the time to offer compassion for the approach, to acknowledge its merits, of which there are many. What does it represent? Encouraging expression. Questioning traditions. Batting aggressively|Attacking with